Chaplin's first film for Essanay was made in the
Chicago studio and presents a fascinating but highly satirical glimpse of
movie-making. Working without a formal scenario, much of the film's fun
was impromptu. A playful jibe at Keystone was made obvious by calling the
studio the "Lockstone." The photography for the film was done by Rollie
Totheroh, then at the beginning of his forty-year association with Chaplin.
The comedians who worked with Chaplin at Keystone were
later to sing his praises. Ford Sterling, Al St. John,
Charley Chase,
Mabel Normand, and Chester Conklin, in recalling the old days, spoke of him with
profound respect. And Mack Sennett was to say, "Charlie Chaplin is the
greatest of all the artists who worked for me, so you know how much I regretted
losing him."
At Essanay Chaplin was first teamed with
Ben Turpin
and on the screen they made a wonderful pair. But Ben, alone among famous
comedians, disliked Chaplin and considered him a snob. Chaplin was too
exacting in his direction; he was reaching for something Ben was never to
understand. Chaplin often exasperated him with his orders to "Do this, do
not do that, look that way, walk like this, now do it over."
In telling of his grievances some years later to
Robert Florey (who described Turpin as a foul-mouthed vulgarian), Ben added,
"Besides, I have since proved that I could work without him. I am now the star
of Keystone, and my films make lots of money."
What was said about
His New Job:
Chicago Tribune
"It is absolutely necessary to laugh at Chaplin in ten-ninths of his antics
in his disaster-attended search for a new job-the small point in which is
evidenced the only irony in the picture."
Bioscope
"There is probably no film comedian in the world more popular with the
average picture theatre audience than that famous fun-maker,
Charles Chaplin,
whose services have recently been secured by the Essanay Company. The art
of
Charles Chaplin defies analysis, and disarms the critic. Just why he is
so funny, it is almost impossible to say, and very probably he could not tell
you himself. He possesses a naturally comic personality and its humor is
accentuated by the originality of the innumerable bits of "business," with which
his work is so profoundly interspersed. Scarcely a moment passes while he
is on the screen, but he is up to some wild piece of mischief or committing some
ludicrous folly. And perhaps the funniest thing of all is his own complete
imperturbability. Whilst those all around him are rolling in an agony of
mirth at his extravagant blunders, he himself pursues his course unmoved, with
an air of mild detachment and stolid indifference. Good humorists never laugh at
their own jokes. They realize the value of apparent seriousness. And, in
the same way,
Charles Chaplin remains emotionless, and even absent-minded, in
the very midst of his maddest escapades."